This past Thursday, Arizona State Senate voted to pass Senate Bill 1091, which will allow residents to pay taxes using Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency that is “recognized” by the state.
The passing of this bill marks a monumental moment in cryptocurrency history. For many years, lawmakers have turned their heads at the idea of cryptocurrency as a legitimate payment process and store of value. Bitcoin’s use in the Dark Web gave the currency a bad reputation and the media latched onto it like a tick on a dog’s back. This past year, cryptocurrencies made numerous headlines and was one of the first years that lawmakers really started to understand the potential of these projects. Arizona State Representative Jeff Weninger, who co-sponsored the bill, states that:
“It’s one of a litany of bills that we’re running that is sending a signal to everyone in the United States, and possibly throughout the world, that Arizona is going to be the place to be for blockchain and digital currency technology in the future.”
Not everyone is on board though. Arizona State Senate Minority Leader Steve Farley said that he believes tax payers will be at risk if the price of Bitcoin drops or crashes suddenly. “If we had a bill that allowed people to pay their taxes in Bitcoin directly, that puts the volatility burden on all other taxpayers because it would mean that that money goes to the state and then the state has to take the responsibility of how to exchange it,” Farley said in an interview with Fox News. He later added his support of the U.S Dollar by saying “These are American dollars. They’re good enough for me.”
To combat the argument of volatility, the bill includes a provision that requires all BTC or any other “recognized” currency to be converted back into USD in a 24 hour time frame in order to be processed by the state. The law has not been fully passed yet and will make its next appearance in front of Arizona’s House of Representatives in the coming weeks. With New York also exploring the possibilities of cryptocurrencies, the first stage of mainstream adoption is upon us.
Wells Fargo Bans Buying Crypto with Credit Cards
In an email to CBS MoneyWatch, a Wells Fargo spokesman has confirmed that the company will now ban all cryptocurrency purchases with their credit cards.
The abrupt decision is “due to the multiple risks associated with this volatile investment,” said the spokesperson, who also stated that “this decision is in line with the overall industry.”
In the past year, Bank of America, JPMorgan Chase, and Citigroup have all banned cryptocurrency purchases. Since the crypto space is hyper-volatile, they are worried that many customers may not be able to pay back the loan. In a poll conducted by loan marketplace LendEDU, it has been discovered that 18 percent of bitcoin buyers used a credit card to pay for the currency. Of that 18 percent, 22 percent were unable to pay off their balance after purchasing bitcoin.
These sweeping changes to policy come after a rough two quarters of 2018. Bitcoin has fallen from around 20,000 USD in December 2017 to around 7,000 USD currently.
It is unclear where the cryptocurrency market will be in the future, but Wells Fargo has stated that they will “continue to evaluate the issue as the market evolves.” In order for these large banks to fully back crypto purchases, the market will need to prove that it is mature and stable.
Bitcoin is Beginning to Trade Like a Commodity
For much of the last year Bitcoin’s price appreciated at exponential levels. Clearly this was due to demand side pressure driving the price upwards, as the supply of Bitcoin, currently circulating at 17,000,587 coins, will only able to marginally increase over time, with a max capacity of 21,000,000 coins. A small, potentially immaterial amount of supply side pressure can be added, as people will inevitably lose private keys to their Bitcoin due to cold storage failure or hardware corruption.
However, in the recent time frame of the last three months, Bitcoin has seen a marked change in its price action. This particular cryptocurrency now has taken on attributes of the price action commonly seen in the commodities market. The two types of traders of cryptocurrency and commodities also share a similar profile. Commodities traders will seek to purchase futures to hedge crop prices needed to run a business or lock in profit on a sale so that they are guaranteed to meet all operational and living expenses. Many Bitcoin purchasers also seek to hedge against the inflation of their local government’s fiat currency or governmental political risk of losing ownership of physical assets in times of political instability.Additionally, speculators in both markets trade the price swings and, at times, can amplify price movements in either direction. While price volatility is seen as commonplace in the cryptocurrency space, the commodities market has its share of volatility also, however. An important caveat to note is the difference of the reference time frame.
We can see the apparent departure from extreme volatility as Bitcoin traded within a 43.60% band from its height in this three-month span.
data source: https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/historical-data/?start=20180127&end=20180427
Here we can see the chart for oil as it fluctuates 73.63% percent from its high over a 5 year span. It is important to note that even blue chip commodities can go on long losing streaks before rebounding.
data source: http://www.macrotrends.net/1369/crude-oil-price-history-chart
It can be seen below that gold fluctuated 27.7% over this 5 year period of time. While it would have been a good choice to hedge against rampant inflation, buying gold on leverage or holding a large position in it would have seen a sizeable downswing for many years in a portfolio.
Bitcoin would have to maintain a track record of many years of trading within a relative band to match some of these long time commodity giants. Perhaps recent volatility can give us hints to a potential price floor and some illiquidity from amongst those owners who keep their coins off exchanges. Regardless of the degree, volatility has, and always will, behoove one to correctly construct a portfolio with asset allocation matching his or her appetite and ability to sustain risk (volatility).
Do like the Winklevoss Twins: Learn How to Keep your Cryptocurrency Assets Safe.
The Winklevoss twins are pioneers in the modern day bitcoin space. They not only started their own bitcoin exchange, but they were also instrumental in creating the public adoption of the title of gold 2.0 for bitcoin. They also were worth an estimated 1.3 billion dollars in bitcoin as of December 2017, giving them the title of bitcoin billionaires. Having such a large fortune in digital asset begs the question, how do the Winklevoss twins keep this safe from most conceivable negative eventualities.
Cold storage is the answer to this question. They use an ingenious system that is more complex than simply writing down their private key on a piece of paper for safe-keeping. Their system, according to Investopedia, is as follows:
“To protect their bitcoin holdings, the brothers distributed snippets of a printout of their private keys across multiple safe deposits around the United States.”
This division of responsibility, of dividing their private keys up amongst multiple parties, makes it increasingly difficult to have a breakdown in their system because many collaborators, in this case not just multiple people but multiple banks, would have to get together in order to perpetrate theft.
Whether or not you have a large fortune in cryptocurrency, there is still due diligence that can be done to keep even your smaller investments, or fractional coins that remain on exchanges, as safe as possible. Whether or not you have a system of cold storage set in stone, it is still a good idea to verify and do research into the brokerage website or App of your choosing.
Agency problems are traditionally between the owners and managers of a business, but there is a very similar relationship between bitcoin owners and brokerage site owners. It is important to note that the problem in bitcoin is that owners of these brokerage sites and owners of bitcoin might not always have the same set of interests. Keep in mind, agency sites make money from fees related to trading and other instruments such as leverage rather than on the actual capital appreciation of the asset. This could incentivize the brokerage side to create or allow financial instruments that actually increased volatility of the assets in which they broker trades. The most common example in the last decade would be the financial crisis of 2008 in which banks ignored their responsibility as underwriters in an attempt to package for sale as many mortgage-backed securities as possible. It is important to understand what types of activities your exchange might be partaking in because inherently risky or illegal activities might possibly lead to your exchange declaring bankruptcy or being shut down by the governing body in the country where it originates.
As of the writing of this article, Gemini maintains that “[t]he majority of digital assets are stored offline in our proprietary Cold Storage system.” And Coinbase maintains that “98% of customer funds are stored offline”. Doing your due diligence and looking into the safety measures and policies of an exchange is essential for giving yourself the smallest possible chance of being a victim of fraud or theft.
Historically, the US has some of the strictest laws governing and regulating exchanges. While regulation might seem inhibitory at first glance, digging deeper we reveal some broadly overarching economic patterns. The legendary Walter Wriston, CEO of Citibank, said “Capital will always go where it’s welcome and stay where it’s well treated.” To be well treated any financial instrument must be transparent and free from fraud or potential abuse. Fair and meaningful financial regulation could be one important step toward generating a positive cash inflow into cryptocurrency projects such as bitcoin that propose to solve some of the world’s financial needs.
Analysis4 months ago
IOTA and the Big “Q”
Alt-Coin4 months ago
Kyber Network Launches Mainnet – Check it out Now
News4 months ago
Crypto Class – A High School Revolution
Analysis4 months ago
Coin Spotlight – NEO
Fundamentals4 months ago
How to Pick Winners – A Guide to Cryptocurrency Research
Fundamentals4 months ago
Dollar Cost Averaging, a Useful Strategy for Any Asset Class
Bitcoin4 months ago
VP of Berkshire Hathaway Wants U.S. to “Step On” Bitcoin and “Let Up” On Wells Fargo
Fundamentals4 months ago
Ledger Nano S: 4 Reasons to Get One Now